My Mulan review
Intro: It’s a shame that we can’t get more female-led movies like
this from Disney.
Mulan: This movie is centered on a girl name Mulan who is
struggling to find her place in a patriarchal regime. Things became difficult when
her ailing father is drafted to fight a war. In order to protect him she goes
in his place impersonating a boy. So, she has to get through training and hopefully
survive the war.
This is the best Disney movie of the renaissance era! What
makes this movie different from other underdog stories is that the stakes are
high for the main character and it’s inspiring. The movie knows when to transition
from being fun to serious. (Take notes MCU) I appreciate the movie for not shying
away from how serious war is without being graphic. This film does what good
musicals do that use the song to express what the characters think and feel. The animation is stylish and the
Chinese wisdom or metaphors are used in a way that you can understand. Both kids
and adults will find the comedy in this movie amusing. The theme of this movie
is earning your stripes, everyone has something to prove. You argue that this movie is a social commentary on gender roles and traditionalism.
Mulan is another good example of how to write a strong
female character! Despite being rough around the edges with living up to traditional standers, she’s
a smart and caring person. She’s not going against traditional norms for the
heck of it she does it to save her father and figure out what she wants to do
with her life. Going against the norms does create tension between her and her
father. The only complaint I have with her is the writers tried to set up a romance
between her and Capt. Shang but it was pointless.
Speaking of Capt. Shang, he's the weakest character in this movie! I say that because he doesn't have much characterization beyond trying to prove that he can lead his army because he didn't earn it. He may be hard on his man, but he does show compassion. We also see that puts his honor above the rules.
Mushu is Mulan's guardian who helps her through her struggles. Mushu is like Starscream but funnier. Mushu is trying to redeem himself with Mulan's ancestors.
The rest of the characters are comic relief.
Shan Yu is the most sadistic Disney villain we have so far. He may come off as a flat character but he's not. He's trying to prove to China that he is as dangerous as they label him as. You can argue that he represents toxic masculinity. (Yes! That's a real thing.)
Chi-Fu (the emperor's assistant) Is not a bad guy, but he does serve as a foil for everyone else. He's the type of slimeball that you want to pound.
One of the problems with this movie is the comedy can feel like a slipstick at times. Because of the time period, this movie takes place in the jokes and dialogue feel out of place. The sprites of Mulan's ancestors make us question what is possible or not. This movie would have been better if it addresses the ups and downs of traditionalism from both the male and female perspectives.
Overall, this is one of those movies that didn't get enough attention. I would recommend giving this a second viewing.
Rating = Worth Seeing